SOL FAQ
- 01. Will SOL be proactive or reactive?
The Party is likely to become very proactive. In fact, we hope SOL will become the most progressive Party in contemporary politics.
The Senator Online website will not only let people have their say on every Bill presented to Parliament, but also have their say on major issues that concern Australians.
When there is sufficient support from the public on certain issues this will concentrate pressure on the Government to act.
It is not common for senators to introduce Bills but they can and in the past have introduced Bills that have had a major impact e.g. Senator Janet Powell’s 1989 ban on tobacco advertising Bill. Driven by issues that concern Australians, SOL senators will be much more active in looking to introduce new Bills.
- 02. What are SOL's objectives?
SOL believes in offering Australians the opportunity to develop their own informed opinion on Bills (being presented to Parliament) and issues shaping our nation, and for those opinions to be clearly heard. We believe this can be achieved by:
- Reaching as many people as possible through an easily accessible medium: the Internet;
- Giving Australians access to accurate information and balanced argument on each Bill before Parliament, and the important issues facing our nation;
- Offering people the opportunity to vote on the Bills and important issues concerning them and their wider community;
- Tallying the votes and determining the clear majority voice which will then be SOL’s view for the vote on each Bill;
- Giving the majority voice a chance to be clearly heard in Parliament above that of the vocal minority—not influenced by party politics or by deal doing;
- Encouraging more people to have a greater involvement in our social and political issues;
- Making our Australian political process more progressive;
- Promoting social and environmental change;
- Actively encouraging government accountability when presenting the case for amendments to existing legislation, or proposing new legislation.
- 03. SOL has no policies, what are its ideals?
SOL has two primary ideals:
We stand for giving the public a clear voice on each an every Bill and important issue, putting "democratic" back in democracy, on a large scale. We believe in providing people with the opportunity for their voice to be heard on every Bill and issue that is being debated in Parliament.
Equally importantly, we stand for the power of informed debate. By using the internet – a great "enabler" of information, we seek to prompt informed debate on the issues that are important to the majority of Australians.
We are not a traditional political organisation whose policies will be influenced by party politics or by vocal minorities or subject to deal doing. We are all about putting the voice of the majority above special interest groups.
Senator Online's view will be the view of the Australian public as determined by its online poll.
As such, it is inappropriate to have predetermined policies.
- 04. How would SOL work?
The current website is a pre-election website that lays out how Senator Online would work if a SOL senator is elected.
In simple terms, for each Bill or important issue people would have access to accurate information and balanced argument via the SOL website. The SOL website would also include a pros & cons section, expert opinion and analysis, the sitting senator's view, and a public forum. People would register, and after registering and being allocated a user name and password, would be able to cast a vote on each Bill or issue.
Most importantly, there would only be one vote per person on Australia's Commonwealth Electoral Roll. People will be able to change their vote.
When there is a clear majority view, this would then be the party view and would be represented in Parliament, enabling the voice of the majority to be heard over special interest groups.
- 05. What types of issues does SOL believe may be on the post-election website?
Issues may include the nuclear power debate, desalination or recycled water, euthanasia or 'natural' death, and whether Education and Health should be federally controlled. Any issue that receives over 10,000 endorsements will be included.
- 06. Who can vote on each Bill or Issue?
Every person recorded on Australia's Commonwealth Electoral Roll will be entitled to join SOL as a 'poll member' free. Every poll member has one vote on each Bill or issue. To participate in SOL's voting process, the poll member will need to have access to the Internet.
- 07. Once I vote can I change my vote?
Yes, any time before voting on a Bill or issue closes.
- 08. Will my vote count and how will the majority view be determined?
Every vote will count.
Where there is a clear majority view, which is determined when 100,000 votes have been cast and there is a 70% majority view, this will become the SOL party view. In the event of votes being less than 100,000 or the majority not reaching 70%, a clear majority view may be able to be agreed on by the party. Otherwise the party's view will be to abstain from voting.
Under no circumstances can or will Senator Online's party view be that of the minority view as indicated in the online poll.
SOL senators will commit in writing to vote in accordance with the party view.
- 09. Could a SOL senator elected by one state vote against a SOL senator elected by a different state?
Yes. SOL is unlike other political parties, who expect all their senators to share the same view, irrespective of which state they have been elected by.
Senator Online's party view may differ for different states as it respects that senators elected by a particular state are incumbent to be considerate of that state's specific concerns. As such, different state SOL senators may vote differently but will require that a clear majority view be determined by the online poll (100,000 state votes and a 70% majority). In the event of votes being less than 100,000 or the majority not reaching 70%, then that state’s SOL senator may vote in accordance with the state's majority view, if a clear majority view can be determined by the party or otherwise the national poll results will be the relevant poll. If a state or territory has less than 1,000,000 people on Australia's Commonwealth Electoral Roll then the 100,000 votes hurdle will be 10% of the then enrolled voters. For example, Tasmania would have (approximately) a 35,000 vote hurdle.
- 10. Will SOL senators vote against the majority view?
SOL senators are required under the SOL constitution, and have undertaken in writing, to vote in accordance with the party's view. The party has been set up to represent the clear majority view. SOL will use online polls to ascertain if there is a clear majority view.
- 11. How can SOL ensure its senators vote in accordance with the majority view?
Before being endorsed and nominated as a SOL candidate for the Senate they will be asked to undertake in writing that they agree to be bound by the majority view, as determined by SOL on Bills before the Senate. SOL asks that persons considering candidature for the party only accept nomination on this basis. SOL will do whatever it can to ensure that SOL senators honour their written undertaking.
- 12. Is security a major issue?
Website security is paramount.
The confidentiality of an individual’s details, together with the integrity of the voting process and its results, are critically important.
All information between the user and the SOL server will be encrypted. All SOL servers will operate under best practice security conditions.
- 13. Will multiple voting occur?
SOL can ensure that only one vote per person registered on Australia's Commonwealth Electoral Roll occurs.
As a registered political party, SOL is entitled to a copy of Australia's Commonwealth Electoral Roll. When voting as a SOL poll member, each person has one vote per Bill or issue. Once a person has voted, they will be 'marked off' the electoral roll and will not be able to vote on that particular Bill or issue again. They can change their vote but this will not count as another vote, it simply supersedes the original.
- 14. How does the voting process ensure that SOL's polls are bona fide?
The validity of poll member's identity and the integrity of online voting are paramount to the party.
To help ensure a bona fide process, anyone applying to be a poll member will be required to register on SOL's website.
The poll member registration process will include but will not be limited to:
- Confirming personal details, including date of birth, home address and middle names, against Australia's Commonwealth Electoral Roll;
- There will be further verification of a person’s bona fides. This may be an automated process likely to be similar to the PayPal verification process where the applicant will nominate a bank account in their name. SOL would deposit two amounts between 10 cents and $1.00. The applicant would need to confirm these amounts back to SOL;
- Once a person's bona fides are established they are then issued a user name and password which the poll member must use when voting.
We are also looking at two factor authentication such as 'passwindow'.
SOL will investigate occurrences of common information existing (for example, email contacts, bank accounts, and computer links) where the poll members have different addresses. When an application for poll membership is received and the identity already belongs to an existing member, SOL will investigate the matter. The investigation will include any links to the fraudulent application.
With these procedures in place, SOL is confident that, for each Bill or issue, there will be one vote per person on Australia's Commonwealth Electoral Roll. Further the greater number of people joining SOL the less likelihood of someone fraudulently registering. In fact under the SOL voting method there is arguably less opportunity of fraudulent voting as compared with voting at traditional polling booths, where the identity of the voter is not verified, there is little to stop those who wish to vote early and often.
- 15. Will the SOL polls be audited?
It is critical that the SOL polls on Bills to be passed are beyond reproach. As such these polls will either be open to audit or conducted by one of the major accounting firms.
- 16. Will SOL's view be representative of the nation's view?
Over 80% of Australians currently have access to the internet either at home or at work. The percentage is greater when those with access through their local library or educational institution are included. If the issue is important enough, then the party's view should be representative given the portion of people with internet access.
SOL expects that the number of people with access to the internet will continue to grow.
- 17. Can a vote be stacked by an organised lobby group?
The integrity of the polls is fundamental to SOL. We are taking steps to ensure that it would be difficult for an organised group to hijack a poll.
The SOL executive will consider the effect that significant, biased and inaccurate campaigns run by organised groups might have on SOL's online polling. The executive will also consider computer analysis of SOL's polled votes if any unusual activity or voting patterns surrounding a vote is reported.
Bills not of national significance will probably poll less than the minimum 100,000 votes that SOL's constitution requires to determine a party majority view. When less than 100,000 votes are polled, the SOL executive, including senators, will determine if a clear majority view is reached.
SOL expects that issues of national significance will result in large numbers of votes, especially given the extensive access to the internet, and because it will be easy to register as a poll member and vote. With a 70% threshold for a majority vote and polling numbers beyond 100,000, it will be difficult for an organised group to change a vote’s outcome.
- 18. Can the party be hijacked by an organised group?
It is important that over the next few elections the SOL objectives and founders stay in place. The constitution provides some powerful protection to ensure the party objectives and executive remain stable for this election and the next.
For instance, the constitution provides that members found to be part of a party stacking exercise may be expelled from the party.
In addition, ordinary member applicants will be required to provide a statutory declaration setting out their current and/or former association with any organised groups.
- 19. Will this result in the country being run by the majority view?
SOL will only run candidates in federal elections for the Upper House— the Senate. Hence if SOL was to be successful it would have the balance of power in one house of Parliament.
SOL is an independent party. It is not aligned to any other political party.
It is neither Liberal nor Labor, where a party view can be determined by the people interested in a specific issue.
Unlike all other independent parties, SOL will not be influenced by party politics, by political deals or by a vocal minority.
SOL's purpose is to be an independent voice for the majority view of its poll members, which should be representative of the voice of the Australian public.
SOL's view is that Australia needs strong leadership.
- A strong leader will educate and inform, not leave people feeling uncertain;
- A strong leader will ask questions, not think they are all-knowing;
- A strong leader will be interested in the community not themselves;
- A strong leader will look to the future, not live in the past.
SOL will aid such leaders.
SOL will provide accurate information and balanced argument. SOL will allow people to become more involved in political debate. SOL will be an accurate barometer of public opinion. SOL is part of the future development of politics.
- 20. What types of membership does SOL have?
There are primarily two types of members.
The first is a poll member. Persons registered on Australia’s Commonwealth Electoral Roll are eligible to apply for SOL poll membership and can vote on all Bills and issues. There are no membership fees in being a poll member.
The second type of membership has three categories. They are the foundation, ordinary and senior memberships. These members can vote at SOL party meetings. Voting will occur mainly when there are changes to the SOL constitution or when there is a change on the SOL executive. These members can not be members of any other political party.
- 21. How can I become a foundation, ordinary or senior member?
Foundation membership is now closed.
Senior membership is granted to ordinary members who remain full financial members for ten years. Anyone interested in joining as an ordinary member, can apply after a SOL senator first sits in the Senate.
- 22. Will I receive unnecessary emails or spam as a result of registering as a poll member?
No. SOL will not give an individual's details to any other person or organisation. SOL will only contact a member when requested or if appropriate.
- 23. Will SOL's financial records be published and audited?
Once SOL has one of its senators elected then SOL's annual financial accounts will be audited and the results published on its website. SOL provides the Australian Electoral Commission with an annual Political Party Disclosure Return.
- 24. Who can gain financially out of SOL's success?
SOL is and will remain a not-for-profit organisation. Any revenue generated from the website or other sources will be used primarily to pay for independent research on Bills and issues. Revenue will also be used to pay for party administration costs.
Currently, SOL executives are not remunerated.
Depending on their time commitments, remuneration may be paid to executives in the future. If remuneration is paid to executives, it will be:
- Limited to an equivalent time portion of a federal senator's remuneration;
- Approved unanimously by the SOL executive;
- Disclosed in the annual audited accounts.
- 25. How will I know when a new Bill is presented to Parliament?
At registration time poll members will be asked which Bills or issues they would like to be notified about by email. A poll member may receive notice on every Bill before Parliament, and all issues on the website, or just those that affect that member.
- 26. Will the SOL post-election website be live when the SOL senators sit for the first time in Parliament?
Yes. The make-up of the Upper House of Parliament will not change until 1st July after the election. The time lag between an election and the first sitting date in July should allow enough time for the post-election website to be in place.
- 27. What input will SOL senators have?
SOL senators will have a commitment to represent the majority view. In additional they will also:
- Have their views on each Bill or issue posted on the website;
- Contribute, as a SOL executive, in deciding if a clear majority view can be determined where a poll does not present a clear majority view, i.e. not more than 70% of the vote or less than 100,000 votes;
- Be encouraged to be on working committees and make recommendations. SOL senators will be transparent to the public by keeping an online diary of Parliamentary happenings and the senator’s thoughts.
- 28. Overview of the Australian Government and how SOL would fit in?
At the upcoming federal election, all persons on Australia's Commonwealth Electoral Roll will be required to vote twice on Election Day.
Once for the House of Representatives (the Lower House )and once for the Senate ( the Upper House).
Australia is divided into 150 electoral divisions, each with between 20,000 and 70,000 voters. From each of these divisions voters elect a person (commonly referred to as their "local member") to represent them in Parliament in the House of Representatives.
The Senate is made up of 76 senators, 12 from each state and two from each territory.
SOL will only be running candidates for the Senate.
Each proposed change to federal laws or proposed new laws are presented to Parliament and are referred to as a 'Bill'. The Bill will generally be first passed by a majority of members in the House of Representatives, and if it is passed here it will then be presented to the Senate. If passed by a majority of senators in the House of Representatives the Bill is enacted and the laws are changed.
As such, SOL senators will be able to clearly express the majority view on each Bill that is presented to Parliament.
- 29. Who will be the SOL Senate Candidates?
SOL is seeking people in each state that it would endorse as its Senate candidates.
- 30. Is Senator Online associated in anyway with, or does it receive funding from any other political party, association or lobby group?
No. Senator Online is independent.
Berge Der Sarkissian (www.bergedersarkissian.com.au) has provided the original concept and initial funding of the party. Senator Online is supported by an executive committee and has in excess of 500 foundation members.
Senator Online's constitution provides powerful protection to ensure the party remains independent.
- 31. What was SOL's 2010 federal election preference policy?
SOL is non-partisan. However, under the current Federal system we must give each party a preference; otherwise we would not get an above-the-line status on the Senate ballot paper.
Accordingly, for the upcoming Federal election after minor parties we will preference the same number of states to Liberal over Labor as Labor over Liberal.
How SOL allocates its preferences for each state will be determined by how these parties preference SOL.
- 32. Why is SOL targeting the Senate?
The Senate's main function is to be the house of review. Bills are normally presented to the House of Representatives and passed there before going to the Senate. This will generally allow the public more time to consider each Bill.
However, in many instances senators simply follow party lines rather than carry out a robust review.
In the event that the public may not like a particular policy of a party they support, or are concerned about the introduction or change of policy they might be unhappy with, a way people can protect themselves is to have a SOL senator in the Senate— a party without any specific policies, but with the commitment that the majority view will be heard in Parliament.
- 33. How practical is SOL? What happens when changes occur, and will people have sufficient time to consider these changes?
The two houses (the House of Representatives and the Senate) must agree to a Bill in identical terms before it is passed. Normally, a Bill is put through the House of Representatives first and once passed it is automatically adjourned to the following period of sitting before being presented to the Senate. There are three readings of the Bill in each house, the Bill becoming public shortly before the first reading. In the vast majority of times, there will be large amounts of time for the public to be considering a Bill.
One of the great benefits of the internet is how quickly information can be passed.
The SOL website will be able to update these changes immediately, and everyone who is interested in this Bill or has voted on this Bill will receive an email update, asking if they would like to change their vote. Replies will also be instantly updated to the SOL website.
- 34. But some Bills need to be passed quickly?
If a Bill is of such National importance that it needs be passed quickly, the government with the support of the Opposition, will have no problems in passing such Bills. However, there are very few Bills that are truly urgent and need be passed without lengthy consideration.
The Senate is supposed to be the house of review. The Senate Rule, Standing order 111, dictates that a Bill introduced in one period of sitting should not be passed to the next house until the next sitting. The principle behind this is that Bills should "sit" on the table so the senators have time to consider them properly.
The facts are:
- The Senate dictates (by majority vote it can put aside Standing Order 111) how quickly a Bill passes;
- So when the majority Senate seats are held by one party, Bills can be pushed through the Senate at the pace the government dictates, without reference to any other senator.
As such, there are broadly two situations that will develop:
Firstly, when a party has in its own right or in combination with another party, the majority of Senate seats. In this case, they can (and do) push Bills through without reference to other parties. The only influence to majority party senators is that of significant public opinion. Senator Online would be a very "pointed" amalgamation of public opinion that the senators of the majority party would have difficulty ignoring.
Secondly, is when a minority party has the balance of power in the Senate, and in effect that party determines the timing of the passage of the Bill. If that party needed more time to consider the Bill or determine what its constituency thought, it would get that time and Bills would be dealt with in a more deliberate and considered manor.
The very vast majority of Bills would, or should, be dealt in the normal manner; the Lower House and then the Upper House both having three readings.
In these cases Senator Online would work well.
If it was an urgent Bill or a late significant and urgent change, there would either be a bipartisan agreement between the two major parties and Senator Online's input would not be needed, or if there was a deadlock, then Senator Online could be used to both deliver and receive information quickly, and so votes would be almost instantaneous.
The Bills Digest is a document produced on every Bill by the federal library, providing background information, a summary of provisions, and gives commentary on the reaction of various groups.
The Digest is produced so that people (mainly used by senators) can be informed about each Bill.
This type of information, plus expert opinions and public forums, is what would be available on the Senator Online web site.
It is important that Bills are not rushed through (unless truly urgent).
Even when a party has control of the Senate (i.e. is able to have Standing Order 111 struck out and push a Bill through), sufficient time should be given such that public opinion is allowed to be considered by those in control of the Senate.
Senator Online would recommend procedural changes to the Senate such that a more deliberate and considered approach to the passage of Bills occurred.
For example, we would recommend that Standing Order 111 be struck out if 75% (as opposed to the current requirement of 51%) of senators agreed.
- 35. Why is SOL not running candidates in NT or ACT
- The NT and ACT only get two senators elected at each election, as apposed to six for each state and as such one seat will go to each of the major parties in each territory. We have very limited resources and can not spend these on territories that we have no chance of winning a seat.
- 36. Our 2010 preferences
As indicated in our preference policy in FAQ #31above:
“for the upcoming Federal election after minor parties we will preference the same number of states to Liberal over Labor as Labor over Liberal. How SOL allocates its preferences for each state will be determined by how these parties preference SOL.” We made contact with all three major parties and split our preferences between the majors as follows:- NSW - Greens > Libs > Lab
- VIC - Lab > Lib > Green
- TAS - Green > Lab > Lib
- SA - Lib > Lab > Green
- QLD - Lab > Lib > Green
- WA - Lib > Lab > Green
For any minor parties or independents to have any chance – the minor parties MUST preference the majors (including the Greens) LAST.
The majority of the minor parties were contacted and we agreed reciprocal similar preferences (although some did not honour what they indicated).
We honoured all arrangements. Minor parties that we agreed to preference each other highly – were Democrats Carers and the LDP. The Group Voting Tickets listing complete preference breakdown amongst all parties can be obtained from the AEC here.